Fallout, Bioshock, Gears of War 2, Halo Reach or Red Dead Redemption?

[Cristian Uriostegui]

Of these five games, which is the best? I'm not sure which games to buy and I want to get the best game for me money. I'm looking for a games with lots of options, replay value and a compelling storyline. I've heard great things about all these games and can't decide which one to choose.
I also would like some multiplayer value. I don't play online but frequently have friends over and need a good first person shooter that has multiplayer features, think one on one.

 

[Josh Mcwilliam]

red dead redemption or fallout 3 RDR is simply amazing but gets boring quickly but fallout 3 is still fantastic to this day my friend was addicted to it for months on end i didn't see him playing a different game for weeks at a time but ill say this give it a chance many of my friends played for 10 Min's and didn't like it because its different let it grow on you